Fighting Oppression: Parallels Between Apartheid Tactics in South Africa and Israel
The Trojan Horse Massacre: Athlone, Cape Town, 1985
On October 15, 1985, in the area around Thornton Road, Athlone, Cape Town, security forces executed a brutal operation that became known as the Trojan Horse Massacre. Using a South African Railways truck disguised with crates to hide armed police, the authorities infiltrated an anti-apartheid protest. As the truck approached the gathering, hidden officers emerged and opened fire on the unsuspecting crowd, killing three young protesters: Jonathan Claasen (21), Shaun Magmoed (15), and Michael Miranda (11), and injuring several others. Although an inquest found the police actions unreasonable, those responsible were never prosecuted. This event highlighted the ruthless strategies employed by the apartheid regime to suppress dissent and maintain control.
Nuseirat Massacre: Gaza, 2024
In a strikingly similar tactic, Israeli forces launched a deadly raid on the Nuseirat refugee camp in Gaza under the guise of a humanitarian mission. On June 8, 2024, several civilian trucks, one loaded with furniture to mimic moving displaced people, entered the camp. Concurrently, airstrikes targeted the busy market area, creating chaos and maximizing casualties. The operation, aimed at rescuing four Israeli captives, resulted in the deaths of nearly 300 Palestinians, including at least 64 children, and injured over 700. Witnesses described indiscriminate shooting and mass executions, with Israeli soldiers reportedly killing people on sight.
Drawing Parallels: The Tactics of Oppression
Both the Trojan Horse Massacre and the Nuseirat Massacre demonstrate the use of deceitful strategies to conduct military operations against civilians. In both instances, authorities used disguise and surprise to carry out attacks, leading to significant loss of life and highlighting the brutality of their respective regimes.
These events underscore the persistent use of covert and violent tactics to suppress resistance and instill fear within the oppressed populations. The parallel between these historical and contemporary instances of state violence serves as a stark reminder of the ongoing struggle for justice and human rights in regions plagued by systemic oppression.
By examining these events side by side, we can better understand the enduring impact of such tactics on the communities involved and the broader implications for global human rights advocacy.
“What’s a house when you’ve lost a country?’ she says with a sigh.”
― Yasmina Khadra, The Attack